Friday, July 30, 2010

An Embarrassment of Riches

We returned to Aix on June 3 and have easily slipped back into the rhythm of life in Provence. Pictures from this period can be found here.


Unexpectedly cold and rainy in winter, the region gave us its nicest weather for the first three weeks: sunny but coolly invigorating. We are staying in a two-bedroom apartment in a complex of about four large buildings. We eat on the terrace which runs along two rooms: shady in the mornings when it stays cool til about 9:30. Then it gets into the mid-90s by early afternoon but usually drops back into the low 70s after dark. (Today, and for the last ten days, the famous Mistral wind is keeping it cool at least through the morning.) There is no air conditioning but a nice pool with just enough shade trees provides a pleasant escape from the furnace of mid-day.


First priority was to buy a car. The requirement of an automatic transmission radically narrowed down our choices, because only about three percent of French drivers buy them and we had to rent a car to drive around the region to check them out. Ours is a small Ford diesel crossover, unlike anything sold in the US but roomy and practical.


I had been waiting for the NY Times guide to summer festivals to plan our travels, only to find that there are literally a hundred times more of them taking place all over France but especially in this area than we had ever heard about at home. The three southeastern provinces (“PACA” for Provence, Var and Alpes-Cote d’Azur) publish a 250 page book with about eight events per page: jazz, classical, rock and world-music concerts, theater, dance, photo and art exhibits, lectures and discussions.


Avignon has its high-end serious festival over 20 days, but it’s “doubled” by the fringe-like “Festival Off” which brings over 800 different troupes to perform 1,000+ long and short performances in every nook and cranny of the town. You just stroll around and respond to the pitches that come at you at every street-corner. And whether for a clown show or a snippet of Samuel Beckett, the leaflets and programs invariably resound with lofty references to Life, Art, Humanity etc.


It’s this high-aspirational artistic and intellectual energy that I find so exciting about France, even though the precious or narcissistic end-product often makes little sense to me. Educational standards are high and people like to celebrate, rather than denigrate, the life of the mind, and are willing to spend public money doing so. But admittedly, sometimes important details get overlooked. Last week we drove to “Jazz a Toulon” for a free 5:30 concert in that port town -- in a lovely little square where we sat at cafe tables and listened to a charming trio of guys accompanying themselves on guitars and percussion. Then we walked three blocks down to the quay to grab a commuter boat across the bay to La-Seyne-sur-Mer, with tickets for a Cuban orchestra coming on at 10 pm as part of its Festival Cubain We walked all over the little resort village without ever finding the concert venue Fort Napoleon; no one had bothered to install any posters and the locals had no idea where it was.


So we have calendared more events than we’ve had the energy to attend, but we’ve done quite a lot. June 21 was the national Fete de la Musique in which every town in France tries to put on as many free musical performances as it can, running all day and as long as possible into the night. We heard a concert in a public park here in Aix: a trio from La Ciotat, the industrial/beach town where we lived last winter. Only they sang in Occitane, an old language similar to Catalan and Provencale, all of them formerly spoken and currently reviving in that band of territory running from northern Spain all the way to the north of Italy.


On July 4 it was provencale (non-lethal) bullfighting before the Queen of Arles, annual contest winner in a town of beauties celebrated in story, song and paint by (Bizet, Daudet and Van Gogh). In Fos-sur-Mer, a newish industrial port near Marseille with none of its own food, history or other “patrimony” to celebrate, they instead put on a festival that revels in a particular color. This year’s was pink; the parade featured men in pink tutus, can-can girls, a rolling piano accompanying a chantoosie singing Edith Piaf songs, pink-suited rockers and a cartoonish machine that blew huge pink confetti over the crowd, plus a group of artists (“Avis de Pas Sages”) from all over France who travel around the country displaying their work in wonderfully decorated small travel trailers.


I never planned to be enticed by tourist diversions like lavender watching, but after one trip to the Vaucluse on a “lavender route,” I was transfixed. The concentrated purple color which I’ve never seen anywhere else in nature, against a backdrop of rich green trees, bright golden wheat and orange poppies, is just hypnotic. We have also driven to a fairly remote area where Provence meets the Alps, and the Verdon River has carved an 2,300 foot slot through the limestone that looks somewhat like the Black Canyon of the Gunnison in Colorado. It’s great hiking, rock climbing (not for us), bungee jumping (maybe for me), kayaking and swimming in the dammed up Lac de Sainte Croix.


Tonight we’ve been invited to dinner by an English guy who is trying to promote Jewish pluralism as against the growing ultra-orthodoxy of the largely North African Sephardic community in Provence. Tomorrow it’s a picque-nique in the Alpilles (near Les Baux and St. Remy) with a French group that seeks to help integrate foreigners, the Acceuil des Villes Frances, which we’ve recently joined.


Next week we have jazzmen Joe Lovano and McCoy Tyner in a former quarry in the nearby town of Rognes, a wine festival on the main boulevard of Aix (buy a glass for three euros and “taste” from 10 am til six if you can last that long). Then it’s to Avignon, where there’s a high-culture theater and opera festival which is doubled by a massive “OFF Avignon” fringe festival which has 900 theater groups (over three weeks) from all over the world enticing audiences to performances on street corners, shops, cafes and churches all over town, all day long. And then to Carpentras, once the home of a vibrant Jewish community under the protection of the Avignon popes (13th-14th centuries) who were then known as “the Pope’s Jews.” We plan to attend a klezmer concert in the old synagogue which is part of a festival of “les Musiques Juives” put on by the Tourist Office and the 80 Jewish families who remain.


I could go on and on, but if you’re still reading this you’ve gotten the idea. Far more than just keeping busy in retirement, we are drinking deeply of an rich culture in an environment of incredible natural and man-made beauty.

Monday, March 8, 2010

Why Provence?

On our first visit in 1985, Aix-en-Provence had an irresistible charm. When we came back with our kids in 1999 we thought “wouldn’t this be a great place to live?” When we arrived in France last fall we thought we’d settle in either Aix, Montpellier or Toulouse. Each had its attractions, but we when we stopped first in Aix and were taken in by Servas hosts Sylvie and Philippe Halle, the choice quickly became clear.

Sylvie housed and fed us for six days, took Karen to markets, connected us with other special people, and took a personal interest in our finding a nice place to live in or around the city.

Since then we’ve had many great times with the Halles: home-and-home dinners, parties with new friends, field trips such as to the Salon du Chocolat, and a guided visit to Le Corbusier’s iconic “Cite Radieuse” in Marseille, hiking in the Calanques (see http://picasaweb.google.com/rpwildau/HikingTheCalanques#) and visiting Philippe’s elderly parents in their amazing home near the Luberon village of Vaison-la-Romaine, built on the third century foundations of a house that apparently belonged to St. Quenin, an early bishop of the town. This weekend I even got to fly over the local area in Philippe’s plane.

So we had every advantage in getting established here, but between Provence and any other region in France where we might have settled, there’s just no comparison. Within 90 miles of Aix we have

  • Cannes and the start of the French Riviera (the “Cote d’Azur”)
  • The fascinating flora and fauna of the Camargue -- Rhone delta rice fields, marsh grasses, flamingos, black bulls (for fighting or eating), white horses, gypsies and their own breed of cowboy.
  • The “alternate-papal” capital of Avignon and towns like Nimes and Arles built on Roman foundations and full of Provencal color that has attracted artists in all ages.
  • Marseille, the third-largest city in France with great art and culture, food and folklore, and its international airport just 25 minutes from Aix.
  • The exquisite high-perched ancient towns of the Luberon range and the foothills of Mont Ventoux made famous by Peter Mayle in “A Year in Provence” and other books.
  • Gorgeous beach towns east of Marseille from Cassis to Bandol -- less chic and less overbuilt but just as beautiful as the famous places on the Riviera.
  • Vineyards and olive groves almost everywhere, but especially north and south of the jagged Alpilles where you find Les Baux and nearby St. Remy de Provence.
  • The Mont Ste. Victoire range visible from most of Aix: “Cezanne’s Mountain” criss-crossed by beautiful hiking trails and sheltering Picasso’s last home at Vauvenargues, 50 minutes by bike from where we live.

Aix itself is the perfect size. It's a brisk walk of 15 minutes across the whole central city; you don't want to drive across it because there's no place to park. There are numerous colleges and universities and an active cultural life. The Anglo-American Group of Provence (AAGP) brings together the large Anglophone expat community (arguably a mixed blessing) and puts on a bunch of programs every month. A mile-and-a-half beyond the peripheral boulevard you're in gorgeous countryside.

And that’s without mentioning the food! Provencal cooking can be salty and features some of my less-favorite items like capers and anchovies. One misses the taste of a juicy steak; the French way of butchering produces more thin cuts and small roasts. The spicy Asian foods I love are at best under-represented. But French food is so good everywhere that one is never unsatisfied. The little snacks you find at bakeries and chocolatiers on every block, the cheese, sausage and bread tastes you are offered in the markets, and even the by-the-slice pizza we get in Aix are a never-ending wonder.

Fortunately my beautiful wife and companion is also a skilled and adventurous cook, so I glide by fine restaurants knowing that there will always be something good on the table at home.

The weather has been a real surprise. We thought the famous South of France would be like a nippier Northern California, but what we got has been colder than Atlanta even in normal years. There have been two major snowstorms and no temperate (above 55 F.) days since early December. (I know we'll be singing a different tune--along with the cicadas--in the heat of summer.) But it’s remarkable how many people are still out and about, jauntily swathed in big scarves, walking, hiking, hanging out, even sitting in cafes!

Finally, it’s amazing to walk down the Cours Mirabeau--the main boulevard of Aix--on a golden winter day, with the facades of 17th century mansions gleaming behind still-leafless plane trees and the streams of the big round fountain catching the sunlight in the Rotonde at the foot of the Cours, and realize that this is home for us, at least for now. So much so that after 10 weeks back in Atlanta, we are coming back here on June 1 for a whole year.

We’ll have a nice apartment for the summer months, and a beautiful house in the nearby country from September onward, and count on having lots of guests.

You’ll find but a small collection of pictures recapping these past months at http://picasaweb.google.com/rpwildau/ProvenceHighlights?pli=1#

Friday, January 1, 2010

Just a-Looking for a Home

The day after our last classes at the Alliance Francaise in Bordeaux ended on November 13 we picked up our Peugeot 308 in Bordeaux and headed south in a big swing that would take us to five days in Spain where my brother Rich and his wife Sharon were trying out their own pre-retirement. This route took us through the departmental capital of Bayonne, the tony resort town of Biarritz and the seaside resorts of St.Jean de Luz on the French side and San Sebastian on the Spanish side. (In the new Europe, the average passenger vehicle such as ours, sweeps into and out of France across international frontiers with Belgium and Spain without even a wave from a border official.)

(Pictures roughly tracking this entry are at http://picasaweb.google.com/rpwildau/LookingForAHome#)

I don't know why I should have been surprised at how prosperous and comfortable these areas are. Maybe I’d gotten the wrong idea from hearing that for a long time the onlypeople who would accept work as sheep-herders in the American West Basques. The Basque language sharing street signs, restaurant menus and museum materials, and the characteristic brightly colored half-timbering on building facades suggest that Basque cultural pride is alive and well, though the secret separatist organization ETA has been quiescent in recent years. The many famous chocolate makers in Bayonne (though unknown to us) were Jews who had fled the Spanish Inquisition; Bayonne also gave us the bayonet as well as wonderful hams which hang in rows over the bars all over the region with little inverted umbrellas inserted at the bottom to catch the fat that drips out as they dry.

The most distinctive eating goes on in pintxos bars, see http://weuropetravel.suite101.com/article.cfm/pintxos_in_san_sebastin_spain where the tapas can be as complex and imaginative as the smorrebrod of Copenhagen. [I know, again it seems to be all about the food!] We were able to find a nice little hotel for two nights on a hill above San Sebastian and enjoyed walking around the town whose beaches are divided by mountainous promontories somewhat like Rio de Janeiro’s. Before heading toward Barcelona we nipped over to Bilbao to see Frank Gehry's Guggenheim museum, of which I may write separately.

Having had almost no previous exposure to Spain, we hated to rush from the Atlantic coast almost to the Mediterranean. The changes of terrain were striking, from the rich green of the Basque country to areas of rocky near-desert in the middle of the trip. Our destination, Girona, is a wonderfully-located place favored especially by big-time bicycle racers who gather there to train in the off season. Rich rented his apartment from one such, Timmy Duggan, http://justgoharder.com/, a contact from Boulder. We took the 75-minute train ride into Barcelona for a two-day stay, heavy on Gaudi architecture, walking the neighborhoods and eating in the marketplace near our hotel. On two other days out of Girona we drove into the Pyrenees and along the Costa Brava, miraculously empty of tourists.

We left Spain with two days to spend on the road to Brussels where we were all to spend Thanksgiving with my cousin Jessica Landman, her husband Dan Mullaney (U.S. Trade Rep to the E.U.) and their two children. The first night we were royally received and housed by my sister Jackie's friend Eric Simon and his wife Isabella in their elegant old apartment in the heart of Lyon. The second we spent in Reims, Champagne country, where the holiday shopping season was just kicking off in earnest with the construction of a Christmas market ("Marche de Noel") consisting of little wooden huts along the main central boulevards, selling handicrafts, clothes, hot wine and edibles of all kinds. We would find that every French town and village decorated with its own particular lighting, consisting of more-or-less elaborate but always artful displays hung in series over the streets. As the holidays approached, these were joined by little ice-rinks where parents and kids skated under the lights and a central venue featuring local music acts, typically announced by radio DJs. The tone of the Christmas commercials have become more and more like ours, but the pace seems just a little less frenetic with whole families seen out doing their things together.

The move from Spain to the Low Countries took us into the heart of winter -- temperatures rarely below freezing but the sun making only occasional appearances. It was a shame not to stop in some of the places we passed through, especially the battlefields of European wars going back at least to Napoleonic times, and the common invasion routes from Germany through Belgium and into France: monuments like Sedan, Verdun, and Bastogne (not to mention Waterloo,a Brussels suburb). Roomy but bursting with our families, Jess' and Dan's home was furnished largely with U.S. government-issue residential pieces and the kids chowed down on such PX-delicacies as stovetop stuffing and instant mashed potatos, but the shortage of electrical outlets is typically European. (As everywhere else we've been, every single socket sprouts its own plug-multiplier or terminal strip.) Mostly it was home-y and satisfying to work on preparing the big feast with family. Over the next four days we tripped off to Antwerp and Bruges for a day each, explored Brussels neighborhoods around the Grand Place and checked out museums including a detailed tour of the Rene Magritte Museum and the former home of Victor Horta, nominally the founder of Art Nouveau. And naturally, there were also the mussels and the frites ("Don't call them French fries," we were scolded) ... and the chocolates. I might have said that we’ve now seen the apotheosis of chocolate, but the surprises just keep coming.

The weather discouraged us from continuing the tour up to Amsterdam, and too often chased us indoors. We didn't have time to go beyond the courtyard of Rubens' house in Antwerp, http://www.rubenshuis.be/smartsite.dws?id=MCE_LANDING&ch=MCE, and I felt like I'd missed the anticipated overdose of florid Old Master art work. I particularly enjoyed the Beguine House in Bruges, http://www.trabel.com/brugge/bruges-beguinage.htm, a community (founded in the 13th century when wars and plagues had reduced the population of men) where unmarried women of faith who didn't want to take nun's vows could live a safe and decent life. The cozy layout of Bruges, in which every view in every direction pleases the eye and car-free zones and splendid public transport preserves the old quality of life, exemplifies the bourgeois richness of those countries. It's certainly attractive in its own ways; it just lacks the charm we find in France.

By the Tuesday after Thanksgiving, we were really ready for some warmer weather and a place to unpack our suitcases for a while. The search for a location until our return home in March had always theoretically focused on three places: Aix-en-Provence, Montpellier and Toulouse. En route to the south, we stopped overnight in Dijon, in a funky kind of Left-Bank hotel with some nice modest restaurants nearby. The town looked infinitely more attractive than when we'd stayed there by the railroad station 24 years earlier. The next morning we avoided the expressways -- stunningly expensive, typically costing as much as the diesel fuel for our comfortable but thrifty car -- in favor of the road down the middle of the Cote d'Or to Beaune, the main stem of the Burgundy wine country. Busily consulting our guidebooks for weather patterns as we drove, an affirmative response from Aix-en-Provence from the first Servas host we'd ever called upon gave us a big morale boost. (Avoid a long explanation of what Servas is by looking at http://joomla.servas.org/).

We stopped for the next night in Orange, just 100 km north of Aix and statistically the warmest town in France. It boasts nice Roman ruins including the most complete theater anywhere, featuring the wall behind the stage which is missing from almost all the others and which creates a rare acoustical environment that has long attracted major opera and other musical productions to the town. On the way from there we stopped in Chateauneuf-du-Pape for a two-hour tasting in the company of a charming young woman with whom we talked about the wine and almost everything else under the still-rare sun. Finally we rolled into Aix at dark and found our way to the lovely home of Sylvie and Philippe Halle -- formerly a barn next to the "big house" of the original owner of the farm, but just ten minutes drive from the center of town. We stayed in a guesthouse connected by a breezeway. Sylvie happens to be the local coordinator of Servas in the region, the mother of three grown children and a true master of every domestic art: such as picking and preparing her own olives, jams, fruit wines, and composing beautiful lunches every day for Philippe, a soils engineer who has built a significant regional business working building sites.

Not only a generous host, Sylvie took us to look at surrounding towns and put us in touch with various websites and local organizations connecting with apartments to rent. She also put us in touch with Marie-Chantal Alinat, a retired psychologist and Servas counterpart in Ceyreste just above La Ciotat, a town 45 minutes to the south, right on the Mediterranean where the weather on average is actually a few degrees warmer. Chantal also couldn't do enough for us, driving us through her own and the neighboring towns including Marseille where we'd never set foot. Though we would return to Chantal's for a party later in the week, after three days in Aix we'd seen the ideal place (though costlier than we'd anticipated) and rented it through mid-March, though it wouldn't be available til January 5.

That left us a week from December 12 within which to check out alternatives for future trips, perhaps in different seasons. First Montpellier, about 100 miles to the west but part of the Languedoc, which has quite a different culture and history than Provence. We stayed there two days with Andre and Joelle Serol, a wonderful Servas couple about our age, also with grown children. Joelle took us into the city on its beautiful new tram (color scheme: orange and chartreuse), showed us around and invited a friend to dinner with us. The center city is the same appealing size as Aix, the surrounding communities maybe less so, but the town is full of students and all the life they create. Definitely worth looking into further.

From there we raced up to Bordeaux so Karen could retrieve her hard-won carte de sejour and we could pick up our checkbook and K's credit card, both too precious for the French banking system to confide to the mail! We took the Fourcherauds out to dinner at l'Entrecote, a small national chain of restaurants where the only item on the menu is a salad, sliced steak in a sauce (Bordelaise, naturellement!) with all-you-care-to-eat fries, and dessert, but hugely satisfying and successful. The next day we met for lunch with our Atlanta friend Vicky Greenhood's sister Jane and her husband Arthur, a Boston couple who have a house near St. Remy de Provence where we later spent a particularly nice overnight visit.

Finally, we stopped in for two nights in Toulouse with Servas hosts Philippe and Josette Chamelat, both recently retired professors, Josette continuing to serve on the Conseil General of their suburban town and on commitees (specifically women's issues) of the Toulouse regional governments. They could not have been friendlier or more fun; Philippe and I stayed up drinking late one night after he'd shown us into and around some of the city's attractions. This is now France's fourth largest city, center of aerospace and high-tech. close to all kinds of outdoor activities so would also be a great choice in any other season.

There were five inches of snow on the ground the day we left. We arrived at Albi, a favorite spot from a previous trip, when everything was closed so we pushed on to Roquefort, where our presence on the snowy last day before the start of Christmas vacation only boosted the population from 700 to 702. We saw all stages of Roquefort production from the happy cows to the curdling of their milk, pressing the curds into molds and hiding them in the unique structure, steady temperature and moisture of the caves, to wrapping etc., shipping, display and ... consumption (ours). On the way south we drove under, but a traffic jam kept us from riding on Norman Foster's beautiful 2004 Viaduc de Millau, http://www.leviaducdemillau.com/ -- just the most recent of the series of architectural marvels to which we've had exposure.

Meanwhile back on the Mediterranean, Chantal took off on a six-month backpacking trip around the world, and left us her house where we've now stayed since December 19. I've taken one breathtaking bike ride over the surrounding hills and we've hiked around the calanques, the beautiful cliffs and inlets along this stretch of the coast. We ate bouillabaisse in a landmark restaurant overlooking the water in Marseilles and were invited for a New Year's Eve drink and ended up being invited to stay for dinner -- fois gras and the whole shootin' match -- with the couple who live next door.

Which brings us up to date. Gilda and John, Karen's sister and our brother-in-law, arrive Sunday night to spend a week with us here and in the new place in Aix. And we haven't even scratched the surface!

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Our Bordeaux Experience

The point of departure for this current trip to France, Bordeaux was a seminal experience. Thanks especially to the inquisitive lens of our host and good friend Jean-Marie Fourcheraud, it has yielded the richest recollection of the time we spent there, from October 21 til November 14, with a quick return on December 14-15. The pictures you will see at http://picasaweb.google.com/rpwildau/BordeauxHighlights02# recap the beauties of the city, our involvement with the Alliance Francaise, our visits to the seat of the Fourcheraud family in the Cognac region to the north, and to the Arcachon basin to the south of Bordeaux. Most importantly it depicts the wonderful times we had with the Fourcheraud extended family and the friends which they consistently brought into their circle. Enjoy with us!

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

La Deuxieme Semaine

Sunday (October 25) was another glorious day. We began at the river's edge on a warm, sunny day. Along the Garonne, there is a wide path where people walk, bike, skate and mingle. There is also a market with the most incredible array of foods for sale. Beautiful produce, cheese in artistic shapes and seasoned with all kinds of herbs and fruits, magret de canard, macaroons of all colors, which we have learned is one of the specialties of Bordeaux, fish, poultry, flowers such as we have never seen in the States-- mini olive trees, cabbage-heads trained up into flowers that look like roses--tantalizing breads, pastries, etc, etc. and also prepared food that one can buy and eat at small tables overlooking the river. Foods from Morocco such as pastilla and lamb shanks, calamari and shrimp prepared in many ways. But the best for us was les huitres crus (raw oysters) and bulots, which are snails from the sea just a few miles away We bought a dozen oysters and a dozen bulots , which come with bread and butter - and of course white wine if you like. We sat at a little table eating, watching the jazz bands including multiple tubas, the river and all the people going by. Then we strolled along the river's edge and admired the market for a short time before we left to link up with a tour we had signed up for to St. Emilion to taste the wine and learn about how it is made.

Chateau Fressac and its surrounding vineyards which we visited was purchased by its current owner about ten years ago--a rich man who took public his washing-machine business including at least 250 stores all over France. So things are apparently not all that different than in California wine country where the dot com rich have done the same things. However we understand that many of these chateaus have been owned by the same families for centuries. Most have large vineyards, unlike in Burgundy, where small plots of land are owned or worked by peasant farmers.

They have been making wine here for 2,000 years, since the time of the Romans. In Bordeaux, all the reds are blended from Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Cabernet Franc. (In Burgundy, the wines are all of Pinot Noir and not blended.) On the left side of the Garonne River, e.g. the Medoc, it's predominantly Cabernet Sauvignon. If from the right, more Merlot. The whites are less well-known, except for fhe Sauternes such as the famous Chateau d'Yquem which are very sweet and generally taken with fois gras, certain cheeses, or dessert.

On Monday, school began. Bob had not expected to attend but the Alliance had him scheduled for classes, and he has found that them quite fun and helpful as well. We go every day from 9 to 12 and two afternoons a week for 2 1/2 hours more for writing. He is in a much more advanced class than me, of course. We are both very impressed with the quality of the instruction and the method.

There are people here from all over the world. In my classes there are people from Algeria, Thalland, Mexico, Turkey, China, Japan, the Republic of Georgia, Germany, Serbia, Brazil, Norway, Sweden, Portugal, etc. The classes are small and we are by far the oldest. Most of our class-mates are younger than our own kids. I find that it is so much fun learning a language. Everything is in French and in class I understand most things. Outside of class is another thing. We have had "cultural activities" which included on Wednesday, a two-hour walking tour to show us the city. There it was harder to understand everything that was said and sometimes it is quite frustrating but every day I learn more of the language. On Friday we had a wine tasting course for nearly three hours, also all in French. Happily, there were materials in English I could look at. More about that later.

On Tuesday, we went to the Prefecture to "regularize our situation" (the French expression) i.e. get me the right to stay here in the form of a "carte de sejour." I now understand how immigrants feel. We arrived at 8:45. It opened at 8:30. The line was already quite long and filled with a very diverse population, mostly Arabs, Africans and people from less prosperous parts of the world. I was among few women without a headscarf. We had to wait an hour and a half for our turn just to find out what we needed to present in order for me to get the equivalent of a green card. We are having a real chicken/egg issue because we have to prove we have enough money to support ourselves and even though we had copies of various brokerage accounts, that was not good enough because the officialdom could not be satisfied that they hadn't been created on the computer. The only solution was to establish a French bank account and get an attestation that we had deposited 12,000 euros (theoretically enough to support ourselves for a year), and our marriage license had to be translated (even though its meaning was pretty clear given that our names were on there along with the date we were married) and also several other things.

Arranging for a bank account sounds easy, right? Mais non. We picked one of the country's largest banks and the first time we went there, no one was available to see us. Everyone was busy! They suggested we come back in two hours. We came back after lunch and still everyone was busy but after some sharp politeness on our parts, they agreed that if we waited ten minutes, someone would be found to talk to us. So, we meet Sophie Vigier, a totally charmless junior banker whose mission seemed to be to say no to everything we wanted. First she said nothing could be done unless I had my carte de sejour. Catch 22 since the prefecture said no carte without a letter from a bank saying that we had money. Then they said I needed an original paper letter from our bank in the US attesting to my bon reputation. They would not call, email or fax and even after we presented it, it could take 30 days to complete the opening ceremonies. Bob said "I don't undertand, We are trying to give you $18,000 and you don't want it? I am an EU citizen. This makes no sense."

After calls to others within the bank, much discussion, and mysterious tapping on the computer, Sophie reconsidered; I still needed a letter but if we deposited the money and the check or wire-transfer cleared, Bob could get an account. Could we get a copy showing the form of such a letter? No, she didn't have it and could only give it to us in person if we came back for it the next day. This person is sitting in front of a computer: one wonders what for! Also, we had to bring our host to attest that we had a contract to live with him and prove that he lived at “our” address (which in fact he has owned for 30+ years) in the form of a recent utility bill. When we showed up with him the next day, Sophie decided that since Bob was an EU citizen, I didn't need a letter attesting to my good character after all, just proof that I was applying for a carte de sejour and that after our wire transfer was received she could give us something to show that to the prefecture. But before she could actually open our account we would have to get a paper from the prefecture showing that we had made application for the carte de sejour. After meeting our smiley landlord she is now our new best friend. We had neither the chicken nor the egg but our problem was prospectively solved.

We ultimately had to spend nearly $130 to have our one-page marriage certificate and various pages from our health insurance policy translated by a court-accredited translator. Hopefully we can get those papers next week. Without a Euro-style bank card from France (containing an embedded security chip in addition to the familiar black strip on American credit card) which many machines now require, we could not order the phone we wanted over the internet. Mobile phone service is very expensive--35 or 40 cents a minute. We found a service on the internet for only 19 cents a minute but it won't take our cards so we have to wait til the bank gives us one. The bank charges about 10 euros a month for the privilege of carrying such a card, which turned out to be only a debit card. So we spent the week arranging for all these documents.

The weather has been wonderful and we have walked to school every day. Good exercise. It is about 25 minutes. Several days, we have brought our lunch, just like in law school, because food here is not cheap. We can sit in a park and eat. One day we ate in a park that was built around the ruins of a building that Charlemagne built for his wife. Hard to beat that. There was a clochard on the next bench. (That is a french wino) Walking to and from school we go through the Jardin Publique. There is a children's section with climbing things and in the afternoon it's filled with little children and their parents, often fathers as well. And on weekend or school holidays there is a puppet show in the park called Guignol Gueran (I think I have spelled that right) which is a particular brand of a sort of French Punch and Judy that has been running continuously since 1853! As Bob would say, it is so French.

On Tuesday evening, we and our hosts were invited for dinner to the apartment of the French girlfriend of Gianvito, the Italian architect who is our fellow-boarder. They are both about 27 and we and our hosts are 60ish It was so much fun to see how a young French person lives. The apartment is quite small. The kitchen is a part of the living room and the bedroom is a small adjacent room with only a beaded curtain between. They were so gracious and don't seem to think anything about the age difference. Carole is a school psychologist who met Gianvito when she was visitng Italy this summer. He is leaving in December so it remains to be seen what will happen with them but they are very sweet together. She made a lovely dinner with hors d’oeuvres in little spoons and individual little square shot-glass containers, which included boudin and sauteed apples with parsley, fois gras with apricot marmalade, shrimp in yogurt (in the spoons) and crab soup in tiny little personal soup tureens. She also gave me the card to let me use her health club for two weeks.

On Friday, the school arranged for a wine tasting and lecture at the Wine School of Bordeaux and for 12 euros each we had a lesson and tasted three wines. The room was set up like a chemistry lab for really serious students with each person sitting on a stool in front of a table with a sink (for pouring out what you don't drink) and a small lamp for looking at the color of the wine. The teacher told us about Bordeaux wines and then about production, etc. and then handed out tiny bottles that contained essences of various smells that one is supposed to find in the wines: cherry, mushroom, vanilla, pepper, licorice, cinnamon, strawberry, etc.. I only got one right! Then we tasted some lovely wine. One white from Graves, one red from Pomerol and a sauterne-like white.

Noemie, the young women employed at the Alliance as “cultural director” has decided to make a movie about the school and the people who attend. They want to film a section about "older" students so they are going to take some film of us and the Fourcherauds at our home. The Fourcherauds are so warm and open and generous. While they certainly do this for the income it adds to their lives, they also truly enjoy having people live and eat and interact with them. Bob and Jean Marie are engaged in constant dialogue and never seem to run out of things to discuss--the business of baguettes, an important topic, social security, architecture, etc.

This weekend, we are at their home in the country. The country, in this case, is the region of Cognac, about one and a half hours away by car. We left about 7:30 Friday evening with the whole family in two cars. That means both daughters, the son-in-law Guillaume and the sweet little granddaughter Alyse. This family is quite close and enjoys being together. The married daughter, Sophie, and her family have had dinner at our house about four times already and we have only been here about ten days. The other daughter takes great pleasure in taking care of Alyse and yesterday brought out her homeopathic kit which contained various essential oils and a book of remedies especially for children. l don't think she has ever made any money from it, and she may just be learning but there are homeopathic pharmacies everywhere.

The manner of child raising is also remarkable, at least in this family. Alyse is only 18 months old but nothing around her is child-proofed, She knows not to touch and the adults seem less hovering. She smiles all the time and is kissed constantly but they don't get down on the floor very much to play games or read to her. But she comes along everywhere and is amazingly good natured.

The country house is in a tiny town called Siecq with about 250 inhabitants. It is where Jean-Marie and his seven siblings grew up and the house he owns there belonged to his grandmother, who among others in their earlier generations were licensed as “bouilleurs de cru” or cognac distillers. The countryside is one vineyard after another with grapes for making cognac as well as our family’s favorite aperitif, the Pineau de Charente. The house is large, dating from the 1890s. The furniture is old and rickety for the most part and some of the walls need plaster and paint but it seems to be how many people live in ancestral homes in the country. There is a large “parc” and garden and an out-building with another kitchen that his grandmere used to use and then carry the food into the home (or the servants did). There is also a small kitchen in the house We used both.

Saturday morning, Bob, Jean-Marie, Guillame and I rode very old bikes (without any gears) through the countryside to meet Antoinette at a farm that sells produce so we could buy things for dinner. We got very lost au milleu de nullepart (eck veldt where I come from) but Jean- Marie had his iPhone along which after much fiddling showed us the way. As you ride along, the fields of vines and corn stalks and the remains of sunflower fields are just lovely and you can smell in the air the grapes which have recently been harvested. Some have been left on the vine and have begun to ferment. They taste like very sweet, soft raisins. After about an hour and a half, we found the farm (which was really quite close as the crow flies). There we picked the sweetest strawberries I am sure I have ever tasted. If I had not picked them myself, I would have sworn they had been covered in sugar for hours. Antoinette also bought vegetables for pot au feu. We had lunch in the garden consisting of deviled eggs, then maigret of canard and mashed potatoes with fresh strawberries for dessert. Just a "simple little French lunch." Afterward, we went up to the second floor in the out-building to have coffee and play French billiards (three balls, no pockets) on a century-old table whose maker's name was affixed to the table by a bronze placque.

Antoinette gathered snails FROM THE GARDEN for dinner. Then she put them in a box covered with chicken wire and sprinkled them with flour which I think she said somehow cleans them of things they may have picked up in the soil. Then they are further cleaned by soaking in a mixture of water and vinegar. In the meanwhile, we all drove over to visit a relative in Vaux Rouillac who makes cognac, some of which he sells to Hennesey (which tells you how good it must be) and some of which he bottles for his own label. His name is Andre Dixneuf. It is speculated that since he was an orphan and orphans are often named for the saint who is celebrated on the day the orphan arrives (there is one for every day of the month) and for the day on which they arrived. He was named after Saint Andre and since he was left at the orphanage on the nineteenth, he is Andre Dixneuf. The label is Dixneuf Pere et Fils. He also raises abeilles (bees) and various vegetables. He is in his early seventies and works with his son and almost no one else. But he seems to do well. He has lots of expensive machinery and land and quite a charming house, beautifully gardened by his very friendly and one can tell once very beautiful wife Jeanine.

And of course, there was Rudy the dog. It seems everyone here has at least one dog. Jeanine took us into her cellar to show us the endives she was growing. It grows from the top of a very large root and you cut it off just as it is ready to eat. If you leave it in the fields, the leaves grow big and green, like chard. But if you remove the root and plant in a big pot covered with cloth and put in the cellar, nice new white shoots spring up, ready for the salad bowl. Who knew?

Then we had a tour of the whole cognac making process, followed by a tasting of several kinds of pineau and some cake. All of this is only in French so I only get some of it. A splendid day, followed by my helping Antoinette prepare the snails which involved making garlic and parsley butter and stuffing each snail with a smudge and baking them. I cannot believe I got to see and do this and they were delicious. All in all it is hard to beat maigret and strawberries for lunch and snails for dinner, all in one day.

This morning, we took a promenade with Jean-Marie around the village. All the buildings are in the Charentaise style, which in part means behind walls and doors. There are no front yards or cars parked in the streets. The town looks deserted because everyone lives behind walls and doors that come up close to the sidewalk. The windows are all closed with shutters so you cannot see inside and most houses have one grand arched door for entry (in the past) by the carriage and a small door next to it for people to enter.

We came back for lunch of fresh shrimp followed by pot au feu and apple tart for desert. Always the tarts or sometimes custard puddings like creme caramel. And always the baguettes. They go every morning for fresh bread, In this little village, the town owns the boulangerie because otherwise it would be hard to keep a baker, who could not afford the investment and would anyway more on to a bigger town as soon as he could. And usually, there is a cheese course. For lunch today, before the tart, we had fresh goat cheese on which they sprinkle sugar.

Bordeaux has a population of about 250,000 in the city proper and counting the environs, about 600,000. Even though Parisians would consider it the provinces, it is quite sophisticated. All the best stores are here if you want them...Hermes, Sonia Rykel, Max Mara, etc. I could not believe the Arche store. I have never owned a pair but the number of different designs and colors is astounding and I may have to break down and buy a pair because they are so beautiful, despite the price. So many shops have unique clothing like you have seen nowhere else. It makes even New York seem like Indianapolis. The city is casual, uncrowded, quite clean and fun. There are flower shops with flowers and plants I have never seen before and it seems like every other shop is a chocolate or macaroon store.

We have been so busy that we have not yet gone to the museums, which have some very good exhibits but next week we should have more time. Nor have I yet gone shopping. but the prices combined with the dollar being so low and the fact that I have to carry it all may well deter me, which is just fine. I already have more than I need. The women here are so stylish and many have long, beautiful, incredibly thin legs. It seems to be in the genes. It is fun to admire them.

And so now, I must close because I must do my homework for tomorrow before we pile into the car to return to Bordeaux.

Karen

Comment Ca Commencait

So...we arrived in Bordeaux Wednesday, October 21 at about 2:30 pm. We made our way to the baggage carousel and found mounted on each carousel an enormous (like maybe 8-foot) bottle of wine. Wine is King here (or Queen) and references to it are everywhere. Outside the window was a short man carrying a sign bearing our name. There was our host, Jean-Marie Fourcheraud waiting to meet us and bring us to where we would be staying. He and Bob have bonded like brothers and even in French, I find myself listening to them talking about cars half the time and war the other half, as Antoinette and I roll our eyes.

We love our hosts. This man is about as tall as me and always smiling. He wears an ascot no matter what kind of shirt he is wearing. He is retired after working for the city in some sort of historic preservation function and is abut 60 years old. His wife, Antoinette, still works and is about the same age. They live in a very modest apartment about a 15-minute walk from the center city and one block from the tram, which itself is incredible. New, clean, fast, quiet, beautifully designed and it seems to go everywhere at a reasonable price.

The Fourcherauds appear to love having foreigners around. About four years ago they saw an ad at Alliance Francaise for host families and signed on and have since become sort of poster-hosts for the AF. They have one married daughter with a charming two year old daughter and another daughter in her late 20s who still lives with them. The apartment is on two floors. We walk up one flight to our floor, which has a small anteroom opening onto a long hall serving four guest bedrooms. Ours is small, maybe the size of an average bedroom like the ones our kids grew up in. It has a very small closet, a bureau with little usable space, a small, student-size desk, one of those college student Asian-style chairs, (round bamboo frame and round saucer-like pillow). Not much for doing anything on and hard to get in and out of. And the bed...it’s called a double, but only for elves. But its only for three weeks and we are being very creative in where we hang things and put them away.

At first there were two other boarders. One was a 60-year-old retired lawyer from Colombia who just wanted to come to France to learn French. His name is Jorge Garcia and he seemed quite agreeable when we had dinner with him and our hosts the first night, but he left the next day. The second boarder is a young Italian architect working in Bordeaux until December. We all share one bathroom but now it is now only us and Gianvito, who isn’t even here very much since he has a girlfriend. Anyway, he gets up early for work so it has not been any problem. At the end of the hall is a small room with a little table for breakfast, a refrigerator, a toaster, a coffee maker and four chairs. The first two nights in our bed were terrible because not only was it small but also it sagged horribly so neither of us slept much, but especially me because my back was acting up and I kept rolling over and then into Bob. This made for not much sleep at all. The problem has been solved, but more about that later.

The first day, after Jean-Marie took us home to drop off our luggage, he offered to take us on a little tour of the town. We had had little sleep on the plane but off we went. We took the tram to the center and he took us around. It is a lovely city, situated on the Gironde River, one side of which is lined with the present or former homes of rich wine merchants and also warehouses. The buildings in Bordeaux cannot be more than four stories high which makes for beautiful views. They were all built in the late 17th century out of sand-colored stone.

Along the river, there is a flat esplanade with water spouting out of it; when the water is off, it surface looks like a mirror reflecting the buildings. The shops are wonderful, filled with things particularly French. Chocolatiers make wine-bottle shaped boxes out of chocolate which are filled with candy and, near the opera, life-size chocolate violins. One shop sold ONLY macaroons in fantastic fluorescent colors that went with their particular flavors--bright purple for lavender, lime green for pistachio, fuschia for I forgot what, bright blue, and dozens of others, including jasmine, cassis, etc. They also make cotton candy in the same colors and flavors (and in chewing gum flavor for the kids.)

The women's boutiques carry unique, Mooncake kinds of styles that I just love, but I am not shopping, only looking. There was one hardware store with ancient hardware that looked like some count in distress must have sold it from his chateau. Anyway, this first walk (much of the area is pedestrianized) gave us a taste of the city after which we returned for dinner.

Jorge was there to join us for an aperitif called Pineau de Charente, which is a sort of fortified wine consisting of cognac and grape juice. Jean Marie is from the Charente where this is made, so it is present at every meal. Antoinette is a very good cook. We find we are eating a bit less since we are not cooking and therefore don't have the huge portions we had at home. I hope this keeps up.

We slept 14 hours and didn't get up the next day until two in the afternoon. I guess we are getting old because jet lag never stopped us before. But the best thing so far is that I am so much calmer than I have ever been on our trips before because I know that if we don't do something today, there is always TOMORROW. I cannot describe what a difference that feeling makes for me. It makes me more patient. I don't even mind that Bob needs to stop to admire and look in the window of every French car he sees and I don't care what time it is anymore. We didn't leave the room that day until five, when we took a walk to check out the route to the Alliance Francaise from our house. It seems to be about 15 minutes. The walk takes us thru the nearby Public Garden, past a flock of geese and ducks, and by a small bridge over a little lagoon.

We went to the Tourist Bureau and arranged for a tour of the St. Emilion vineyards and the neighboring town on Sunday. After that, we went across the street to the Maison du Vin, an elegant small office-building that has been converted into a wine school and beautiful modern restaurant that feels like the Upper East Side of Manhattan, and where you can taste the best wines of the region by the glass for very reasonable prices while you watch a lush video about the wine area and read maps and brochures about some of the world's greatest wines--Pomerol, Margaux, Pauillac, St. Emilion, Mouton Rothschild, etc. That evening, our hosts' daughter, husband and two-year-old girl, and Antoinette's sister joined us for paella. All the conversation is in French. No one speaks English. I am surprised at how much I understand and how willing I am to try to speak French. I thought I would be embarrassed but I am not. I would say I understand about half but I have much to learn and I am anxious to start school on Monday.

After another sleepless night, we awoke at 11:30. We never do this. We left about 2:30 and stopped at a boulangerie for two way-too-large and way-too-rich pieces of quiche which we ate sitting on a bench in the park across the street, in the warm drizzle that was Friday's weather. We barely noticed. Then we stopped in a tiny epicerie to admire the perfect, and perfectly trimmed and displayed fruits and veggies. We had a lovely conversation with the proprietress who explained that the neighbors love to come there because of the "personal attention" and the quality of the produce. We saw a lady buy ONE shallot which was sold to her with a smile. How they make a living I don't know.

The owner seemed to enjoy talking to us and was quite open and friendly, as have been all the people we have met so far. People have stopped us in the street when we look lost. I think all this stuff about how cold the French are is an urban (Parisian) legend. I found my eyes tearing up again as I enjoyed the conversation (and even understood much of it) and admired the gorgeous leeks, tomatoes and fennel, few though they were, that looked like Dutch paintings. Tearing up because again, I just couldn't believe we were actually here, actually living here and having so much fun. Then we saw a Club de Forme, a fitness club. We stopped in to see what it offered and how much it would cost. Great facility but too expensive, but even that was fun since it was part of trying to create a life here and keep some of the things we like to do but do it the French way.

It is so easy to travel these days with Google to help you with your any need and Kindle to hold all your books, including your guide books, and your BlackBerry to email if necessary and guide you with its GPS system. Wifi (“wee-fee”) is free here and seems to be quite available. And of course at night, there are my ever present books on tape on the iTouch. It does make for a lot of charging, however. And some things must not change. We listen to the Jim Lehrer Show and Morning Edition as they stream in on the computer. Tomorrow we will listen to Prairie Home Companion. I can't believe we can even do that.

Last night, we had dinner alone with the Fourcherauds and they are so kind and charming. They have traveled quite extensively and been to many of the same places as we have so we enjoyed sharing stories and seeing their photos. They are genuinely interested in other people and Bob is having great political and philosophical discussions with Jean Marie who has just the best characteristics of the French. He reminds me of Maurice Chevalier. He breaks out into song and dance every so often and wants to show us everything. They have invited us to spend next weekend at their family home in Charente.

We were concerned about the sleeping arrangements because even though we want to be adaptable, it was difficult to contemplate three weeks in that bed. We knew there were other rooms that appeared to be empty, including the one Jorge vacated, but we were unsure of how to raise the issue of the bed being too small. At dinner, while we were having such a comfortable conversation, Bob gingerly mentioned that the bed was un peu petit. Oh, they were up and looking for how to solve the problem before he finished his sentence. They offered to let us use Jorge's room for sleeping; we could separate the bed into two mattresses or one of us could just use that bed. No extra cost and it is really nice to have the two rooms because the other has a futon-like couch and a large table we can really use. So now everything is perfect.

Today the Fourcherauds took us for a picnic in the Medoc area, to a small town called Blaye. All along the way we followed the Gironde River until it merged with the Dordogne to form an estuary. The harvest had just finished in the vineyards all around us. The vines are now turning the colors of autumn and the views along the river are spectacular. Our picnic was sooo French--chevre, great French bread, which they really do still buy one at a time and carry home. The crust is so wonderfully crunchy. Prosciutto and saucisson sec, rillettes of chicken, tomatoes and of course the local wine.

When we first got to Bordeaux, Jean Marie asked if there were any foods we did not eat; did we like fois gras and escargots. I have died and gone to heaven. These are not rich people so who knows if I will ever eat those things in their home, but I loved being asked. In the evening we went to the festival of new wine and the brocante which means flea market. It was a few blocks away in front of a cathedral. The new wine is basically grape juice that is just beginning to ferment. it is yellow and bought in wine bottles that have no label. Everyone gets a bottle and some plastic glasses and walks along drinking it in the street. It is awful. And the vendors are selling fresh oysters. Bordeaux is quite near the ocean. All of this showing us around is really not part of our hosts’ responsibilities but they seem to enjoy doing it. Tonight for dinner, Antoinette made raclette with a home-style raclette machine. Who knew? Again, we feel so fortunate to have met our new friend Allen Shulman, who put us on to Bordeaux and to the Fourcherauds.

I have gone on way too long. Most of you have probably already pressed the delete button and I don't blame you. One last thing. There is an expression Bob picked up long ago: the words of a now-forgotten German king who supposedly described the good life as “living like God in France.” I think I now understand what it means. Good people, great history, art and architecture, beautiful flowers, wondrous food and wine. The fun of learning a new language and new culture. We are truly blessed. And now I will press the send button and hope this finally gets out because if it gets lost I can't do it again.

Much love,

Karen

Monday, November 9, 2009

Vive la Diffe-rance!

Though we've only been back in France for three weeks, it's hard to resist talking about how different the French world-view is from our own.
I'd expected to find more changes in the French outlook since I'd left in 1967. However troublesome it had been back then to obtain a work visa entitling me to stay indefinitely, I took it in stride as part of the adventure of living in a foreign country. Having employment with French companies before my first visit to the Prefecture of Police gave me an ostensible reason to be there in the first place and even a certain credibility.
This time, after waiting in line with the huddled masses at the Prefecture for over an hour, all we could get was a list of the required documents. When we came back with our court-approved translations, etc., we could see the the official behind the counter narrow her eyes to search for defects, which of course she found and marked by adding details to the list -- presumably already accurate and complete -- we'd been given the previous time.
No French person who hears this tale has the slightest sympathy. Sure, we know that foreigners don't have an easy time with our immigration officials, but the ordinary Frenchman encounters the same attitude every day and accepts it as a fact of life. He may have to make multiple trips to the office of the Securite Sociale, but there is a payoff in the form of real health security.
Much of what we are learning about economic life in France has come from our readings and writings at the Alliance Francaise, We've had whole units on work-life, including working conditions (much concern over "stress") and the problems young people encounter in finding employment. Nicholas Sarkozy came to power in May, 2007 on the campaign theme of "working longer to earn more." You might be surprised to find this a controversial notion, considering that his starting point was the 35-hour work week that had come into effect just seven years earlier! There doesn't seem to be much dissent to the original idea that underlay the reduction of working hours, namely that cutting the jobs into smaller pieces would reduce unemployment by spreading the work around to more people. But additional hiring didn't follow, it is said because French workforce regulations make it too hard for employers to lay people off when business conditions change.
The employer-employee relationship takes various contractual forms defined by law, notably the CDI ("indefinite duration" thus presumably permanent) and CDD ("definite duration" thus expiring within two years and renewable only once). Except for graduates of the elite schools ("grands ecoles") and high tech talent, folks in their 20s are often stuck with CDD jobs or worse. Because of the perceived insecurity of such employment, they can't qualify for mortgages or even car loans. In short, the mobility of labor is hamstrung by regulations that neither American employers nor workers would ever accept.
Defenders of these arrangements, such as our host, say that, sure, companies can lay off CDI employees when conditions warrant, but if challenged, employers have to prove such business necessity to the satisfaction of a government agency. He considers employment security a natural concomitant to healthy family life and thus a compelling national interest requiring the government constantly to balance the interests of business and workers against each other. In the U.S. by comparison, mentioning "Main Street and Wall Street" in the same breath is about the closest you can come to suggesting that their interests differ, before being accused of inciting class warfare.
What I find interesting is that political life here doesn't seem to suffer by the fact of such social stratification being acknowledged. Some say that French people accept their roles in life and don't assume that they will climb the socio-economic ladder (attain the "American Dream") as our people do. I couldn't make that judgment, though for instance there's no shame in being a "peasant" in France. But from the outside, it looks like the French are pretty successfully defending their interests in a good quality of life within their system. Consider by comparison the costs Americans are now paying for having pretended that the "ownership society" could be bought in a few years' time with cheap mortgage money.
I don't even understand it enough to argue that we should emulate the French model, but neither should we be too quick to dismiss it or predict its demise. If we try it, as with a government healthcare option, a lot of Americans may find they like it too.